Should Christians Protest?

March for the alternative, central London

One of the world’s foremost Christian communicators, J John of the Philo Trust, commented on the place of Christian protest in this month’s EA Magazine.

The last eighteen months or so, has certainly seen a huge rise in public protests in this nation. We’ve seen students and their supporters protesting the massive hike in tuition fees and the scrapping of the EMA. There’s been the public sector’s strike over the attack on their pension agreements and Occupy London with their camp on the very threshold of St Paul’s Cathedral protesting the burgeoning power of the financial institutions and the widening gap between rich and poor in this nation. In the first half of 2011 there was also the protest ‘March for the Alternative’ where  around half a million men, women and children marched as one to be a voice to the Con-Dem coalition government in what was  the largest union-organised event for 20 years. Ordinary people making their voice heard in extraordinary times.

J. John, in his article asked a very important question: as Christians, should we protest? Well, I did last year, for the first time in my life I attended a public protest. I was one of many ordinary people on the ‘March for the Alternative.’ Central London was brought to a standstill as workers of all kinds: NHS staff, teachers, students, pensioners, postmen and at least one church leader marched peacefully through London to a rally in Hyde Park.

I was faced with a bit of a dilemma, I’d previously booked into the newfrontiers ‘Everything Conference’ scheduled for the same day. Should I attend the Conference, with an opportunity to learn, network, pray and talk about societal change or do I act for change by attending the ‘March for the Alternative’? As I’ve already stated, I decided on the latter. In the spirit of Alfred Salter, Keir Hardie, George Landsbury and others, I wanted to do something to protest and challenge an ideology that dismisses the ordinary working man with arrogant disdain. Although the so called Big Society is a great opportunity for churches to impact their communities further; it is not the answer. To quote Keir Hardie:

Poverty can never be remedied by charity, but only by justice.

I was marching for justice. The social and geographical gap between rich and poor is as wide now as it was in Victorian Britain, and getting wider. Does that matter? I believe it does. It matters a lot. I am passionate to see people become Christians; to experience forgiveness and salvation and find their place in the Kingdom of God and the assurance of a home in heaven but I’m also passionate that as Christians, we should fight for justice and dignity and stand with the people who suffer as a result of injustice. People who are facing unemployment, uncertainty, displacement, homelessness and poverty as a result of the cuts imposed by this government.

As I took part in the ‘March for the Alternative’, I was seeking to be ‘a shining light and a city on the hill’ while at the same time adding my voice to the growing shout for a viable alternative.

Historically, Christians in this nation have been at the forefront of protesting over issues of justice but in recent years they’ve have taken a much more negative approach to public protest. But as J John asked:

 Is our reluctance to protest really the outworking of a genuine prayerful godliness; or about a moral laziness and indifference? Apathy masquerading as piety is a poor show. More importantly, our governments actually expect some measure of protest. Increasingly it seems they create and announce policies with little thought and even less consultation and then – fingers crossed – impose them on the public. If they are met with strong objections, then the policies or laws are hastily withdrawn, redrafted and resubmitted. In a culture where only those who shout are heard, any failure to protest may be presumed consent or approval.

 Let’s not be guilty of moral laziness, indifference and apathy when we encounter injustice, as J John said in his article: Protests are an opportunity to show that actually we do care for others. Protest can be pro-testimony.

Comfort in a Cold Climate

Easterhouse Glasgow

Thirteen years ago today the Spice Girls were sitting on top of the music charts with their third successive Christmas number one, ‘Goodbye’ and Manchester United were on their way to an unprecedented treble. There was no financial crisis, more people had jobs and pension funds were comparatively healthy.

Thirteen years ago today on Wednesday 23 December 1998, Bob Holman had an article published on the BBC News website. His comment on affluence and the extravagance of a commercialised Christmas is even more relevant today and just as thought provoking as it was thirteen years ago. I’ve reproduced it here in full:

Comfort in a cold climate

Bob Holman brings Christmas cheer to harsh surroundings

BBC News Online is presenting a series of personal viewpoints on Christmas from Christians from all walks of life. Bob Holman, a voluntary neighbourhood worker on the Easterhouse council estate in Glasgow, here explains how the focus of his Christmas is bringing seasonal cheer to a deprived area.

In Britain today, Christmas has been hijacked by affluence. But I doubt that the carpenter from Nazareth would be comfortable in such an atmosphere of extravagance.

Instead he would probably feel more at home with me at Easterhouse, in a dingy hall where those who can’t afford expensive presents are glad just to meet and share fellowship at this time of year.

Easterhouse is probably the largest council schemes in Britain and houses some of the UK’s most underprivileged families. Over 80% of its pupils receive a grant which is an indicator that they come from homes with very low incomes.

Nonetheless, Christmas is a special and joyful time for residents – many of whom are special in their own right.

Captain Christmas

I moved to Easterhouse 12 years ago with my wife Annette. We soon became involved in the Christmas celebrations when Salvation Army leader Captain Eric Buchanan – having learnt about my former aid work on a council estate in Bath – drew me into the first of many Sally Christmases.

Christmas in Easterhouse starts on the Sunday before with a carol service. It ends on Christmas day with lunch and a party for families who do not have the money for turkey and trimmings.

At the carol service, a packed hall enjoy the women’s choir, watch the nativity play acted by children dressed in towels and blankets and listen to the army leader’s humorous address.

One year, the Captain Buchanan was energetically leading a carol when he suddenly stopped and walked out. After a puzzled silence, Annette initiated “choose your own carol” to fill the gap.

It turned out that the captain had seen a needy person enter through the back door and that person had instantly become more important than anything else.

At the Christmas Day party, I have the hopeless task of organising the games for excited children – and parents – until rescued by the arrival of Santa Claus. The hall is dingy and its windows covered with wire protection but it becomes a place of laughter.

Faith in the poor

One regular at the party used to be Erica and her family. Abused as a child and then a teenage prostitute, her life was changed at the Salvation Army.

I remember calling on Erica one Sunday afternoon when the family had just 15p in the world. The children wanted it for sweets but Erica refused. That evening at the Salvation Army she put it in the collection.

In a book written largely by Easterhouse residents called Faith in the Poor, Erica describes how she made a stable life for herself and the importance of the Easterhouse Christmas.

She wrote: “Christmas Day at the Sally was great. I was in the women’s choir which Annette led. I never missed a Sunday service and the Captain and Mrs. Buchanan were a part of our life.”

Merry Christmas.

As we celebrate Christmas 2011, we must not forget the many individuals, families, and communities like Easterhouse, up and down the country who continue to suffer from both the effects of recession – poverty, joblessness and hopelessness, and from a lack of the gospel story – forgiveness, dignity and hope. What should we do as we move into 2012?